In the pub after DM, we discussed a few site issues. Also some administration changes.
Here are the ones I can remember:
1) Site membership must be using your real name. No exceptions. This is a site for publishers and creators and all our real names appear on the cover of our books. So everyone must sign up to the site with their real name as it appears on their gas/electricity/phone bill.
1a) How is the spam filtering done? Is it by post or by user? Surely it's easier to filter users signing up manually and then let them post whatever they like once they prove they're not a ruskie pornbroker?
2) Threads do not jump to the most recent unread post. This is particularly bothersome when the thread is more than 25 posts long because you have to click the thread, scroll to the bottom and then hit next and wait for the next page to load....
3) Timestamps on posts and the order in which they appear are changed if posts are edited.
4) There's no GUI for formatting posts.
5) I want a pony. Why haven't I got a pony?
6) The "New Posts" thing bears no relation to the actual number of new posts. Quite often the time of the latest post on the front page of the forums is wrong too., this used to be much worse, but it's still rubbish.


I heartily agree with number
Submitted by Malcolm Craig on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 12:40.
I heartily agree with number 1 on the list. I think that using your real name is a great thing when it comes to openness and non-dickery. Not that I'm saying that people are being dicks currently, but I do think that real names are the way forward.
We'll also be demanding three forms of identification and proof of income.
Cheers
Malc
Contested Ground Studios
Hmm. What do you suggest
Submitted by Alex Fradera on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 13:57.
Hmm.
What do you suggest doing if you aren't currently posting with your full name? Delete account? Full name in signature?
Alex F(radera)
London based indie gamers - we try to get stuff rolling via here
http://www.sunnyblue.net/forum/
IIRC, Matt said it's pretty
Submitted by Rich Stokes on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 14:36.
IIRC, Matt said it's pretty easy to change people's usernames. If it's not then we might have to address this, but I'm sure there's a way around this.
Hey Alex
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 14:51.
I just changed your user name as an illustration. It's very easy for admins to do.
Oh, of course I can change it back to Alex F if you'd prefer that.
Yay!
Submitted by Rich Stokes on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 15:02.
Hoorah, it didn't break!
Also
Submitted by Matt on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 15:15.
Anybody who asks for Member status can change their username themselves.
I changed the signup form intro on Sunday, so it should display a brief note saying what we'd prefer. I'm loathe to enforce it to heavily, some people have reasons not to want their name all over the 'net. Me, you have to go fifty pages into Google before you get somebody else when searchign for my name...
Re: 1a. We get a lot of spam signups. This is a product of being search engine visible, and using an open product. It's easy for spammers to write software to take advantage of that.
GUI is coming when I have a spare moment.
-Matt
Realms Publishing
Thanks Gregor!
Submitted by Alex Fradera on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 17:52.
I did have a poke about couldn't figure out how to do it solo.
London based indie gamers - we try to get stuff rolling via here
http://www.sunnyblue.net/forum/
Issues
Submitted by David Donachie on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 21:52.
2) That's a known issue in Drupal's comment module, which doesn't know what size of pagination is in force on the page where the comment appears. I'm crossing my fingers that Matt has a solution up his sleeve, which I can then beg him to let me steal for the forums on my site :)
3) Again a core Drupal issue, I guess you could replace the forum pages with views based on Creation date rather than modification date - but that said, I think the way it works now is pretty much what I would expect for threads, its the ordering of replies that is weird.
4) I've set up the Drupal I'm using at work with TinyMCE as a visual editor, and it seems to work pretty well, I certainly like it more than FCKEditor (which I have also used, and which has a painful setup process).
And finally .... if (1) is going to be policy then maybe you could change my name too Gregor?
Solipsist RPG, on its way ... eventually
David...
Submitted by Malcolm Craig on Wed, 05/12/2007 - 23:42.
Hey David,
I changed your username, but may have mis-spelled your last name. If I've got it wrong, just let me know and I'll sort it.
Cheers
Malcolm
Contested Ground Studios
I couldnt find any option to
Submitted by Andrew Watson on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 07:48.
I couldnt find any option to alter my username. Nothing in the edit tab seemed to work.
Also, could I second the issue about edited posts moving. I found it very frustrating recently when posting my Cold City AP. I posted each scene as its own post but every time I edited one I had to edit all of the others to keep them in order.
Andrew Watson
Currently Playing: Cold City, Pendragon
Currently Testing: Duty and Honour
Hey Andrew
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 09:18.
That's your name fixed too.
Name
Submitted by Ben Clapperton on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 14:19.
My real name is Ben Clapperton. Change away!
I'm not GB Steve either
Submitted by Steve Dempsey on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 14:33.
Change it if you like.
Steve
I have an urge to change everyone's name...
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 14:56.
...to Spartacus.
That's changed now, GB Steve.
And so's my wife!
Submitted by Rich Stokes on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 15:02.
...to Spartacus.
Surely Brian would be more appropriate, given how the general conversation has been headed?
Real/full name
Submitted by Graham W on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 15:37.
I'm happy to be Graham W, which is my real name, but not my full name. (My memory of the conversation in the pub was that we agreed on real names, which I like, but not on full gas-or-electricity-bill names).
I think that's explicit enough so that I'm not anonymous. People can still come up to me at conventions and say "You wrote that thing...".
I was only my full name before because I didn't think I could change it.
This stems from when I was developing Gay Recruitment Squad, which I didn't really want people to find on the Internet, when they searched for full names.
Graham
No problem
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 16:04.
I like Matt's point above about it being our suggested preference, and the decision left up to the individual.
Otherwise to be known as...
Submitted by Tim Gray on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 18:49.
I'm happy to be Graham W, which is my real name, but not my full name.
...Improvised Spice!
(Sometimes the mandatory post title is a bit of a pain.)
Tim Gray
Silver Branch Games
www.silverbranch.co.uk
Oh
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 20:29.
On mandatory post titles I have found myself using "Oh", "Um" and other such exclamations to, well, effect (not sure if it's good or bad effect but you get the point).
I'm sure we'll all have a bit of adjusting to reading people by new names at first, so maybe there is something to be said for keeping a well-known handle.
It possibly makes spotting the latest wave of Chinese spammers (sgdgjfefuyui, FEEEERthhdj, etc.) easier to spot...
Well as long as we keep our
Submitted by David Donachie on Thu, 06/12/2007 - 21:58.
Well as long as we keep our icons we should be okay ....
Solipsist RPG, on its way ... eventually
[Pointless title]
Submitted by Rich Stokes on Fri, 07/12/2007 - 08:07.
It possibly makes spotting the latest wave of Chinese spammers (sgdgjfefuyui, FEEEERthhdj, etc.) easier to spot...
I take it this means that sign ups are not human moderated then?
No
Submitted by Gregor Hutton on Fri, 07/12/2007 - 09:06.
No human moderation on sign up (and given the volume of spam that's maybe a good thing). Akismet does a brilliant job of spotting them when they post and blocking them though.